Cakes • Pies • Cookies • Croissants & More
Made From Scratch
Cakes • Pies • Cookies • Croissants & More, We are having a tentative opening on November 23rd
Made From Scratch, come join us
Get To Know
The Farmhouse Baker
Farmhouse Sweets is run by Rebecca Shuster who specializes in crafting delicious treats made from scratch using only the finest ingredients. From classic cookies and cakes to innovative pastries and pies, every item on the menu is thoughtfully prepared with care and attention to detail. Whether you’re looking for a sweet pick-me-up for yourself or a crowd-pleasing dessert for a special occasion, Farmhouse Sweets has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. Call today to discover Rebecca’s warm and delicious baked goods made from scratch.
Previous
Next
read testimonials from
Our Happy Customers
“Wow! 100% impressed! This was not the first time I’ve gone to Rebecca for my baked good needs, and it will certainly not be the last. My first occasion using her talents, she made my son’s high school graduation cake. I showed her some ideas I was thinking of. She was professional and thorough as we worked through the ideas together and with her amazing talent, she made it a reality. It was gorgeous and delicious.
Rebecca has been my “go-to” multiple times for any and all pies I’ve needed over the last couple of years. Once you’ve had one of these pies, you will never go anywhere else. I just can’t say enough about how amazing they are. Most recently, I ordered a couple dozen Easter egg cookies for an event. They were individually wrapped. The comment we got the most was that “these are too beautiful to eat!” But, we got over that quick and devoured them.
I highly recommend Rebecca and Farmhouse Sweets. 100% you will not be disappointed.”
Kirsten
"As an original member of the Farmhouse Sweets pie of the month club, I am uniquely positioned to say — Holy cow, Rebecca can bake!! And not just pies, but the whole gamut of baked confections. I’ve eaten and baked a lot of pies. But honestly, None have consistently held up to Rebecca‘s. Baking is both science and art and Rebecca truly has a gift for it. Her crusts are always perfect. Her fillings always ideally spiced and textured. My favorite food, not my favorite pie, my favorite food, is her Keylime pie. Her apple crumb is a close second. And don’t even get me started on the cranberry pear.
I just had a slice of this month’s selection. Shoo-fly Pie is usually not for the faint of heart, but Rebecca‘s touch made it great. Again, a perfect flaky crust, and the toned down and puffed up filling was far better than the original Pennsylvania Dutch article.
Rebecca also provided a lot of the baked goods for my son Kirby’s wedding to the irrepressible Sonya this past fall. Her linzer tarts and hand pies were hand-in-hand with the wedding cake. A small wedding, but everyone raved about Rebecca’s contribution.
Please join the club and have Farmhouse Sweets bake your next dessert. "
Bernard N.
Previous
Next
Join us for
Our Events
Check back here to see where you’ll be able to find Farmhouse Sweets and its great products! We appreciate your support and would love to see you with us!
Hackettstown Farmers Market
Farmhouse Sweets will be at the Hackettstown Farmers Market starting May 5th! See more dates below.
- May 5th, 2024
- May 12th, 2024
- May 19th, 2024
- May 26th, 2024
- June 2nd, 2024
- June 9th, 2024
- June 16th, 2024
- June 23rd, 2024
- July 7th, 2024
- July 14th, 2024
- July 21st, 2024
- August 4th, 2024
- August 11th, 2024
- August 18th, 2024
- August 25th, 2024
- September 1st, 2024
- September 8th, 2024
- September 15th, 2024
- September 22nd, 2024
- October 6th, 2024
- October 13th, 2024
- October 20th, 2024
- October 27th, 2024
Cookie Decorating Classes
Join our cookie decorating classes at Czig Meister Brewing Company, Hackettstown, NJ. See the dates below!
- May 8th, 2024
- June 5th, 2024
Mother's Day Cupcake Bouquet
Join us for our Cupcake Bouquet at Arctic Foods in Washington, NJ on Saturday, May 11th, 2024!
Blue Ridge Winery
Farmhouse Sweets will be at the Blue Ridge Winery in Saylorsburg, PA on the following dates:
- June 22nd, 2024
- July 6th, 2024
- July 20th, 2024
- August 3rd, 2024
- August 17th, 2024
- August 31st, 2024
- September 14th, 2024
- October 12th, 2024
- October 26th, 2024
- November 9th, 2024
- November 23rd, 2024
Donaldsons Farm
Find us at Donaldsons Farm in Hackettstown, NJ on September 7th, 2024 for their Sweet Corn and Garlic Fest! More dates to come.
Other dates
- We will be supplying lavender macarons to Orchard View Lavender Farm in Port Murray, NJ starting May 3rd.
- Some of our products will be sold at Ort's Farm in Long Valley, NJ starting Mother's Day weekend.